10 Shows Like “Tell Me Lies” That You Would Like To Watch in 2024

Tell Me Lies portrays the evolution of a complex relationship spanning eight years. Created by Meaghan Oppenheimer, the series stars Jackson White as Stephen DeMarco, and Grace Van Patten as Lucy Albright, delivering a drama rich in intrigue and deception.

The show delves into the dynamic between the complex characters over an extended period. This detailed approach provides a unique viewing experience, allowing audiences to witness the intricacies of the relationship. 

10 Shows Like “Tell Me Lies” in 2024

If you would like to watch more shows like Tell Me Lies, start with the following series.

1. You’re The Worst (2014-2019)

Stream on Hulu

The well-praised FX original series takes a darkly humorous approach, but You’re The Worst also delves into the lasting impacts of a harmful relationship much like Tell Me Lies. The storyline revolves around Jimmu and Gretchen, a couple engaged in a self-destructive romance, going to great lengths to maintain a doomed connection.

Popular for its clever humor, and well-developed characters, You’re The Worst combines serious themes with a light comedic flair. This makes it a standout series in television history. There’s no doubt that You’re The Worst is one of the best shows like Tell Me Lies.

2. Pretty Little Liars (2010-2017)

Stream on Hulu/Amazon Prime Video

Think of Pretty Little Liars as a bit more dramatic compared to Tell Me Lies. It’s about a group of teenage girls dealing with a mysterious stalker who wants to reveal their deepest secrets. Even though it’s more of a mystery than a love story, there are common themes between this popular Freeform series and Tell Me Lies.

The girls are on a mission to keep their secrets safe and find out who the mysterious stalker, known as “A,” really is. Amidst all this, there are some not-so-healthy teenage relationships, like the forbidden romance between Aria, who’s underage, and her high school teacher Ezra. Yes, Pretty Little Liars is a bit of a goofy teen show, but it shares similar themes with shows like Tell Me Lies.

3. Big Little Lies (2017-2019)

Stream on Max

HBO’s super popular show Big Little Lies, which won 8 Emmys, is a lot like Tell Me Lies. It’s all about the troubled marriage between Perry and Celeste. Celeste faces violent abuse at home because she can’t fight back. 

This story echoes many themes found in Tell Me Lies. Until Grace shares her struggles with her closest friends, she’s stuck in a life of sadness, even though she has a luxurious lifestyle. The first season of Big Little Lies, filled with amazing actors, is a great match for Tell Me Lies. Both the shows dive into how keeping deep secrets messes with your mind, and how our unchecked desires can bring us down.

4. The Affair (2014-2019)

Stream on Prime Video

In Tell Me Lies, a big part of the story is about Stephen and Lucy’s long-term affair. If you are into shows with stories about cheating in marriages, you should check out The Affair. It’s a highly respected series from Showtime that won Best TV Drama at the 2015 Golden Globes.

The show is all about the secret relationship between waitress Alison and writer Noah. They feel a mix of sadness, loneliness, regret, and even love for each other as they deal with the serious consequences that will change their lives forever. The Affair has fantastic acting and dives into the deep desires and emotions of people, making it a must-watch if you are a fan of Tell Me Lies.

5. Behind Her Eyes (2021-)

Stream on Netflix

In Behind Her Eyes, things get a bit mysterious, but the main focus is on Louise and her emotions as she starts a secret relationship with her married boss David. The story takes a twist when Louise forms a strange connection with David’s wife, Adele. It’s steamy, full of melodrama and a great pick if you enjoyed Tell Me Lies.

While Tell Me Lies has more detailed characters, Behind Her Eyes keeps you hooked with its unexpected twists and turns right from the start. Even though the two shows go to different extremes, they both dig deep into themes like romantic obsession, cheating, and how one small decision can shake up many lives.

6. Yellowjackets (2021 -)

Stream on Showtime

Yellowjackets, a Showtime series starts with a terrible plane crash in 1996, where a girls’ soccer team has to survive in the tough Canadian wilderness for several months. The show keeps you hooked by switching between the girls struggling in the woods and their adult selves in the present, trying to solve a death case.

Even though it might seem different from a show like Tell Me Lies, both series use time jumps to show the audience the full range of the characters’ lives and the outcomes of their choices. The series explores how secrets, lies, and conflicting personalities among these girls can turn deadly in a survival situation.

7. Normal People (2020)

Stream on Hulu

Like shows such as Tell Me Lies, Normal People tells a story where characters’ choices have unintended negative impacts on their relationship. This miniseries focuses on Connell and Marianne during their college years. The series follows their attempts to navigate a budding romance amidst personal struggles.

Normal People shares a similar pace and tone with Tell Me Lies. It highlights the social power dynamics between Connell and Marianne. This miniseries explores the challenges of their broken family lives, making it an excellent watch for fans of Tell Me Lies.

8. Euphoria (2019 -)

Stream on Max

Euphoria stands out as a show that captures toxic relationships among teens, making it one of the best choices for fans of Tell Me Lies. The toxic duo, Nate and Maddy both want to harm each other in the name of love. However, the main focus of the show is Rue, a teenager dealing with OCD and bipolar disorder, transitioning from rehab and returning to high school.

As Rue navigates her life, she forms a romantic connection with Jules, a new girl with her share of toxic relationships. The Euphoria ensemble cast deals with a range of challenges, from addictions to heartbreak and secret romances. Just like Tell Me Lies, Euphoria is filled with lies and secrets, earning critical acclaim along the way.

9. Sex/Life (2021-2023)

Stream on Netflix

The sizzling drama Sex/Life is a top pick for those who liked Tell Me Lies. In this show, Billie Mann Connelly starts having intense fantasies about her wild past as a party girl. When her ex-boyfriend Brad reappears, she can’t resist reliving those moments, even though she still loves her kids and husband.

Sex/Life is essentially a one-woman show led by actress Sarah Shahi as she unravels the dream life she built. The relationship between her and Brad is a toxic one, with Brad trying to win her back despite her being married with children. With only two seasons, it’s a perfect weekend binge for fans of Tell Me Lies.

10. Big Love (2006-2011)

Stream on HBO

Big Love is one of the best shows similar to Tell Me Lies. The drama revolves around a Utah handyman named Bill Henrickson with three wives, all living under the same roof. While it might seem different from Tell Me Lies, the core theme of Big Love is about maintaining family unity despite strained romances.

What sets Big Love apart is the consensual aspect of Bill’s so-called infidelity, as he consistently shows favoritism towards one wife over another. This dynamic has led to psychological unease among the wives over the years. The series is filled with white lies, and dark secrets, making it one of the most intriguing domestic dramas ever.